Writing this was like trying to pass the biggest, stankiest, greasiest yet most unpleasantly-dry-and-full-of-partially-chewed-brazil-nuts-est shit ever
WITH MY MIND! I feel like my brain has haemorrhoids. I've seen a lot of so bad they're good films and even more that are so bad they're horrible but this is the first film I've encountered so bad that it's
actually evil. This film shreds your critical faculties while you watch it. This film
reduces hardened feminist critics to inarticulate rage. If you still haven't guessed it rhymes with Trucker Funch, which, by a curious coincidence, is the only sexual act that can still bring Zack Snyder to orgasm.
 |
| Snyder's here. We need a pint of engine oil, a lubricated chain, a full English breakfast that's been left in an airing cupboard for 3 weeks and get the girls to glue boar bristles to their noses. Remember, it's OK to vomit. |
I don't think you're stupid if you find
Sucker Punch empowering. As a small child, I managed to take a message of gay equality and feminist empowerment from
'Allo 'Allo and you have to push your brain into a very strange shape to do that. Learning to almost automatically extract the meaning you want from the culture surrounding you and firmly ignore the bits you don't like is a valuable life skill for the marginalized, which still mysteriously includes 52% of the human population. If you're able to quarry some joy out of
Sucker Punch then I'm happy for you but...
There are really good reasons not many people will share your viewpoint.
I'm not going to critique the cast, they're all terrible but they really never had a chance. The
film is glossy but all it's shiny images just remind me of better
films they're cribbed from. There's some OK music on the soundtrack. The action scenes are mediocre and manage to make the most interesting things unexciting but I don't think any of this is why
Sucker Punch flopped. It flopped because this film is the distillation of everything that's slimy, pandering and
dishonest in nerd culture and being so overtly pandered to can make
people feel uncomfortable. The nerd backlash against this film may be the result of giving the straight white cis male demographic that it's aimed at a "Naked Lunch" moment. Stuff like this gives masturbation fantasies a bad name.
The
opening music video shows Babydoll's mother dying, followed by her wicked stepfather finding that her estate has been left to Babydoll and her sister. He tries to kill them (with rape heavily implied). Babydoll then wins the William Burroughs Memorial Award for outstanding marksmanship when she tries to shoot her stepfather in the head,
misses
and somehow manages to kill her sister who was lying on the ground.
Which is one hell of a trick shot. Unless she'd already been killed by her stepfather somehow. It's only the most important event in the protagonists life that will drive and motivate everything she does so it's understandable that Snyder doesn't want to waste a lot of time here. There's shots of woman crying in fear and/or despair to get to.
Women crying in fear and/or despair for various reasons form an important motif in
Sucker Punch and each character gets to do her own variant or "look". This is so you know it's empowering. For example, here is Babydoll doing her best "My sister's been killed and I've been falsely imprisoned in a lunatic asylum".
 |
| I'VE NEVER FELT MORE SELF-ACTUALIZED. |
But I'm getting a little ahead of myself. After her sister dies, Babydoll's stepfather has her committed to a hospital for the mentally insane.
 |
| At least he didn't put her with the physically insane people. Those guys are mean. |
This is presumably because if it was for the criminally insane (you know, people who shoot their relatives), we might question if helping the other girls to escape is a good idea. If the other girls actually exist - but more of that later.
Anyway, her stepfather has conspired with the corrupt orderly Blue to have her lobotomised in a week. While they're quibbling over the details, Babydoll gets to overhear the asylum head Dr Gorski giving another patient (Sweet Pea) a treatment session (curiously, the asylum seems to offer only two forms of treatment, psychodrama and lobotomies). Inspired by Gorski's platitudes about imaginary worlds she can control, as the icepick descends, Babydoll (maybe) creates one for herself.
In this world she's a ingénue sex slave imprisoned in a high-end bordello that also functions as a burlesque house. She's got a week before the fabled High Roller shows up to rape her. Exactly why she's decided to retreat to this fantasy world which is possibly even more depressing than the one she's stuck in (if a bit gaudier) is anyone's guess.
It's important in a film that deals with multiple layers of reality to have some way to keep track of where the story is at any given time. In Sucker Punch, each layer of reality is signified with a layer of eyelashes on the main character. Incidentally, the film does make a point of telling us that Babydoll is 20 so although she's supposed to look like a heavily made-up schoolgirl it's totally OK to want to fuck her. Seriously, the Snyder's down with that.
 |
| Ohhhh yeeaaahhh! |
Anyway, in the imaginary bordello, Babydoll will have to perform menial chores and attend mandatory ballet class, like all sex slaves.
 |
| Lingerie clad ballet is absolutely integral to the smooth running of this hell brothel. |
She meets the other girls: Rocket (the nice but spunky one), her sister Sweet Pea (the head girl), Blondie (who isn't blonde, how clever) and Amber (the Asian one). Fortunately, as we live in a post-racism society, it's not necessary to give Blondie and Amber any further characterization.
 |
| We look forward to dying on your journey of empowerment, noble white heroine. |
The other girls are catty and hostile (as all women are) but Babydoll saves Rocket from being raped by the piggy cook and this gives her an in. Then, when she's nervous at her first dance practice, Madame Gorski (in this world she's a brothel madame who works for Blue) gives her a pep talk that basically amounts to "Empower yourself with your coerced sexy dancing". With this motivation, Babydoll promptly drops into another level of reality where she's a mangaesque ass-kicker by way of
Showgirls. She meets an old Wise Man who speaks in clichéd aphorisms (which Snyder seems to find hilarious). He tells her she'll need 5 things: A map, a knife, a key, fire and a mysterious sacrifice (which is obviously going to be her). Then she battles three robot samurai that painfully remind you that you could be watching Brazil instead.
 |
| BUT OUR FX ARE TECHNOLOGICALLY SUPERIOR! |
This is still the best action sequence in the film, mostly because you might harbour some hope that this means something, some sort of inner demons that she has to conquer or a symbolic representation of her escape plan (spoiler:it doesn't). She comes back up to the brothel at the end and finds that her sexy dancing has the power to completely hypnotize all the men who see it's magic eroticism (no, seriously). We never see this dance but as she was jumping around killing imaginary monsters in her head, I'm guessing it looked a lot like the magically erotic dance of
the Star Wars kid.
Now she has a plan to present to her fellow sex slaves. She'll use her ability to do hypnotic sexy dancing while imagining heavily CGI dependent sci-fi/fantasy scenarios, to distract the men while the other girls steal the required items. Rocket, being the nice but spunky one, is all for it. Sweet Pea being the bossy, grouchy one, is against it but reluctantly agrees. Blondie and Amber are not white and therefore will go with the majority, rather than risk character development.
The first item is the map and the scene where Sweet Pea breaks into the office to copy it is in serious danger of becoming suspenseful so we move to what's happening in (maybe) Babydoll's head. She's imagining a steam/dieselpunk version of World War One (or Two, it's unlikely Snyder knows the difference). This sequence is filmed in a stuttering sepia that lets you know that Zack Snyder has seen
Saving Private Ryan. There's a bunch of steam powered Nazi zombies and a bad guy who looks like Freddy Krueger dressed as The Red Baron and the girls (women just doesn't seem to stick as a term here) are some sort of strike force sent to grab a map (see it connects, not in any meaningful way but it connects).
Shall we take a moment out to discuss the costumes? Not just costumes;
sexy costumes. Babydoll isn't just dressed as a schoolgirl, she's dressed as a
sexy schoolgirl.
 |
| The slit skirt is for empowerment. |
Rocket isn't just dressed as an WW2 infantrywomen, she's dressed as a
sexy WW2 infantrywomen.
 |
| This is what right-wing men see when someone talks about women in combat. |
Sweet Pea isn't just dressed as Joan of Arc, she's dressed as
sexy Joan of Arc.
 |
| The Maid of New Orleans? |
Blondie isn't just dressed as...
 |
| Sexy cowgirl? Sexy Biggles? |
Actually I have no clue what this costume is supposed to be. But it's supposed to be
sexy. Because, for a women, being
sexy is the key to
empowerment. Intelligence, talent, inner strength; all require a solid basing in
sexy.
You may have noticed I haven't mentioned Amber. As the groups pilot, she doesn't get to show off her
sexy outfit as much so she gets less to do. She gets a mecha, a plane and a helicopter but these are only
cool, they're not
sexy.
So there's a bunch of fighting and Babydoll shoots down a zeppelin
 |
| Oh the humanity. |
and gets the map. that's about it.
Back in the the brothel, Blue wants to put Babydoll on stage. Madame Gorski doesn't think she's ready so we get a scene of him humiliating her. Who's supposed to be imagining this or how it relates to the "real world" where she's actually his boss is anyone's guess. Blue then returns to his office and realizes the map has been copied at which point we realize that everything they're going to do will be noticed immediately. This is the shittest plan ever.
As the girls haven't realized that this is the shittest plan ever, they're gearing up for the next step and we have some character development for Amber after all. She's scared she'll be caught stealing the lighter. Fear of death is a character trait (sort of).
They talk her into it and Amber's rich client is introduced in an annoying music video accompanied by
a truly vile track that does terrible things to helpless, vulnerable Queen songs. This is in no way meant to glamorize forced prostitution.
 |
| Dehumanising women is just plain wrong. |
Babydoll dances and imagines a cod-Tolkein battleground where the gang have to retrieve two crystals from a baby dragons throat that make fire. The mother dragon objects, which actually seems pretty reasonable. It all ends in Babydoll stabbing her in the head. When this kind of thing can happen
without it being even a little bit exciting something has gone terribly wrong with the universe.
As the girls are sitting congratulating themselves on the succesful theft of the lighter, Blue comes in to tell them he knows they took it, menace and rough them up a bit, without actually making them give it back. Sweet Pea wants to stop the plan now but a crying Rocket insists on going ahead. Here she is doing her "I'd rather die than live like this".
 |
| Despair and defiance. That's like double empowerment. |
Blue has been partly successful as in the next scene the pressure of living a lie has gotten to Blondie. Madame Gorski finds her crying in the rehearsal room doing a very creditable "The fear of discovery is more than I can bear".
 |
| I'm not even white! |
She decides to confide in Madame Gorski, too empowered to notice that Blue is there as well.
Meantime the rest of them are off trying to get the knife from the cook. Just as the highly recognizable customized lighter was the only source of fire, the only knife in this kitchen that is designed to service all the slaves and clients of a luxury bordello is the one in the cooks belt. Fortunately as well as being a rapist, the cook is also extremely gullible so doesn't question their sudden need to give him a lap dance. This time, Babydoll's imagination has them trying to defuse a nuclear bomb guarded by killer robots on a monorail on an alien planet. What has that got to do with knives you ask? Nothing. Absolutely nothing.
 |
| My existence was meaningless. |
Unfortunately, the radio Babydoll is dancing too shorts out and the cook notices Sweet Pea taking the knife. He's so enraged, he ends up stabbing Rocket to death. As he's also the cook in the asylum, does that mean that Rocket actually has been stabbed to death (this is not real remember). Blue arrives and gets everyone to the dressing room for dramatic confrontation purposes, where he finds the list of items still on the back of the chalkboard. Presumably because their little womanish heads would've forgotten everything if they hadn't kept it written down in the most obvious place. Empowerment abounds in this scene. Here's Amber's impressive "I'm about to be shot in the back of the head".
 |
| At least I had a richly drawn character arc. |
Blondie doing "If only I hadn't betrayed myself and all my friends with my dark haired weakness".
 |
| This kind of challenging role is why I became an actress. |
Even Madame Gorski gets to cry, proving that Zack Snyder respects mature women. A lovely "If only I hadn't collaborated, I was fooling myself all along."
 |
| Empowerment for everybody. |
None of them can do anything because women are only powerful in dreams. Actually even in dreams they're not powerful, women are only powerful in the dreams they have when they're dreaming.
Blue orders everybody out but Babydoll so he can give in to temptation and rape her. She stabs him with the knife which makes me wonder why her plan wasn't simply 1) Steal knife 2) Get Blue alone 3) Stab him and take his key. She and Sweet Pea leave the bordello but there's a crowd of men standing at the gate. Rather than try to think of a distraction, Babydoll decides to sacrifice herself by kicking one of the men in the groin, providing a distraction so Sweet Pea can escape. Him punching her in the face corresponds to the icepick lobotomising her.
Back (finally) in the real world Doctor Gorski realizes that Blue faked her signature on the lobotomy order and has him arrested as he is about to rape the lobotomised Babydoll. This points up the obvious flaw in the films "your mind can set you free" bullshit, in fantasy brothel world Blue is all powerful and Gorski is his helpless subordinate. In the real world, he's just an orderly and Gorski's the boss and sympathetic to the girls. If she hadn't been so busy with imaginary battles and had just talked to her, Babydoll could have avoided being lobotomised.
Anyway Sweet Pea escapes on a greyhound bus thanks to the kindly driver who is the wise man from Babydoll's dancing trance. The whole thing was in Sweet Pea's head all the time. How does that make any sense? Did we ever find out if any of the girls was actually killed in the real world? What kind of asylum requires mandatory fake eyelashes?
Snyder's die-hard nerd supporters
* claimed that the editing necessary to get the film down to a PG-13 rating from it's original R is why it's a mess. In the interest of being fair and finding answers, I watched the director's cut when it became available. There's a few extra bits and pieces, a fight scene in Tolkein world that's better than most of the ones that got left in but nothing special. The really important extra scene is the one at the end between Babydoll and the High Roller. In interviews, Emily Browning had
bemoaned the loss of a scene where Babydoll got to "actually take control of
her own sexuality."
It turns out that in the film as planned, after being knocked out
Babydoll wakes up to find herself in the High Roller's bedroom. It turns out that the High Roller is Jon Hamm doing his best imitation of a pick-up artist. This sterling fellow disavows any interest in forcing himself on Babydoll, claiming that all he wants is "one honest moment". Won over by his eyelinered charms, she breathlessly gives herself to him willingly, in no way coerced by the fact that this is her only way of escape from the hell brothel. The moment he kisses her is what now corresponds to the icepick. Am I the only one who thinks this actually makes things worse.
In Snyder's world, taking control of your own sexuality for a young woman means selling it. I say Snyder's world advisedly because it was the
the director himself who finally explained the film to me.
It’s funny because someone one asked me about why I dressed the girls
like that, and I said, “Do you not get the metaphor there? The girls are
in a brothel performing for men in the dark. In the fantasy sequences,
the men in the dark are us. The men in the dark are basically me; dorky
sci-fi kids.”
This quote explained everything that's wrong with the film to me. I know I've already mocked the costumes but a simple image search for cosplay shows that lots of people, of all genders, like imagining themselves as problematically sexualized asskickers in impractical outfits. For the films real problem, let's go back to the first shot of the film, Babydoll sitting in the stage set of her room.
The film's "real world" explicitly isn't the real world.
Sucker Punch doesn't take place in Babydoll or Sweet Pea's head. The only head this film takes place inside is Zack Snyder's. There's a fourth level of reality we don't see where Snyder is watching this, watching us watch this, and he's got his hands down his pants. Everything in this film, including the constant threats of rape and shots of crying women, is only in it because Snyder wants to see it and wants us to watch as well. He's got no interest in telling a coherent story, let alone artistic truth. If the bordello can't make up it's mind if it's horrific or sleazily glamorous, that's because Snyder can't either so it switches back and forth. This is a film about the value of an inner world that refuses to let it's characters have one, they have precisely the same depth as Snyder's collection of real dolls (which I imagine he owns but never cleans).
I think that's why
Sucker Punch got so far up my nose. I've always been fascinated by stories where people carry their own universes around with them in their heads that interact with reality in unpredictable ways and, despite how problematic, silly or poorly realized a lot of them are, I still feel that action heroines have an inherent subversive potential. Zack Snyder has taken both these things and metaphorically smeared his swollen, intentionally pus-leaking, scrotal sac over them. I'm not saying that he gets off deliberately infecting himself with rare venereal diseases then passing them to as many unwitting people as possible
 |
| Who could believe such a thing of this face? |
just that
Sucker Punch is the closest filmmaking equivalent.
Anyway, that was ridiculously long but better out than in and now I never have to think about this film ever again.
 |
| Not in this film you can't. |
*Nerd supporters are the least flattering underwear ever.